cake a fare logo

Custom Cakes

Your dream
is our design.

Attention to Detail

Drumsets to rosettes. Geo-crystals to Mickey Mouse. Details that make your cake unique.

Custom Designs

We’ll collaborate with you to design the cake you imagine. Small or large, traditional or exotic–your custom cake can tell your story.

Variety of Cake Types

Diverse sizes, shapes, and mouth-watering flavors. Check out our work on the gallery page.

Don’t settle for average.
Shoot for the stars.

Does baking for birthdays stress you? Are you afraid your fairytale wedding cake is out of reach?

Celebrate with a themed birthday cake that delights your child or a wedding cake that tastes as good as it looks–you imagine it; we create it.

Explore our cake fillings, flavors, and icings.

This list is not all-inclusive. We welcome your special request and will make any flavor, filling, or icing for your cake.

Starts at 5.00 per person and up based on design for wedding cakes only

Our Cakes and Baked Creations

vw car cake
Specialty Cakes
Happy Birthday Cake
Birthday Cakes
Wedding Cake
Wedding Cakes
Cake Rolls
Cake Rolls

Cake A Fare Customers Are Saying

Jamie was so easy to work with. I was blown away and almost cried when I saw my son’s Ninja Turtle birthday cake — he was ecstatic! The cake tasted amazing, was very reasonably priced and looked outstanding. There is nothing I would have changed about our experience.
Chelsea Manning

Order your Dream Cake Today

1.   Call us to communicate your dream.
2.   Relax while our cake designer creates a masterpiece.
3.   Celebrate with friends and family.

Let Us Take Care of the Details

Drawing on her 27 years of experience, our talented chef will design and create the cake of your dreams. We’ll set up a meeting to hear your goals, and then we’ll take it from there. For weddings, we offer deliveries to the venue. Check out our gallery to see our work.

Stay in Touch

Follow us on social media. Find us on The Knot. Keep up-to-date on our productions and share what you love about Cake A Fare.

498 E Lincoln Ave.
Myerstown, PA 17067

Get In Touch

Visit our Restaurant